I am not an actual Straussian.
I'm reading the History of Political Philosophy edited by Strauss.
And I've read Natural Right, some of What is Political Philosophy and I'm going to read a couple more just to see what he has to say.
But I am not obsessed with Strauss.
To give a few reasons why:
I believe in a Jared Diamond version of history
which basically means
resources create situations
and these situations bring about events
Like for me
when the Europeans found the Americas
the world was able to combine
wheat, rice, potatoes and corn in their diet
which created a super amount of caloric intake for the humans
we had the renaissance which created Reason and Empiricalism
which as far as I can tell was created
because Europe took an interest in Aristotle in the 1200s
then the Black Death created a decline in religious belief
then the popes of the Renaissance sucked really bad
which led to Luther which killed off religion and replaced it with a social club.
Then the renaissance happened which was led by the fact that Europe was reading Aristotle and not Plato. Aristotle led to science.
Then for many reasons the populations grew
which demanded large scale production
which created wage labor capitalism
capitalism leads to people living for MONEY
not for God or a life in the after-life
this also all led to democracy
democracy uses the separation of powers to make sure Great Men do not arise
for men must always compromise in a democracy
this is called the separation of powers
Then we found coal, oil and natural gas
God dies because we don't need to go to heaven anymore because we have Taco Bell and cable television.
I believe these things not to be determined but very much situational
This is not in tune with Strauss who never considered the impact of resources on man's morality.
And to me morality often leads to racism, sexism, and murder.
The Muslims of Saudi Arabia have morality, they believe in things, which lead to women getting murdered and obeying princes.
Americans probably believe in justice and freedom and some believe in hard work.
Why they believe in them, most have never thought about it, probably the main belief of Americans I hate is their love of gas guzzling cars and suburban sprawl. Which isn't part of their core beliefs, but the fact they do not believe in duty to their fellow citizens and nature.
ALSO
Strauss has this thing concering secret meaning in political philosophy
I don't care about that
Political philosophy has gotten a lot of people killed
and it has made a lot of lives better
if someone was adult they would be looking at what kills and what brings food and justice to people.
ALSO
Strauss thought that relativism made fascism and Communism.
The Christians killed each other and Muslims constantly from the Fall of Rome to the Renaissance. Sometimes you really wish that a philosopher had to show at least one graph or some empirical data.
I think he was just hoping his readers didn't know history.